Alex Kate moves towards her balcony which has a swing chair .. She sits there, her hair flying with a light breeze and she looks so breathtaking. I sat with her and said ' Kate I... I don't know how to start but believe me, my intention was never to hurt you... but I always do hurt you ... and maybe I will still hurt you in the future but please forgive me ... I'm so so sorry ... when Shawn and mom told me what Helen said and did I just felt that I should kill myself for insulting you and not supporting you.... kate please say something ... hit me.. yell at me... god I deserve this but please say something' She was still not looking at me. She had a very calm but sad expression and saw her tears that put a dagger in my heart I picked her face and plead with her to say something