Valerie's POV That i***t is with Brenda. He lied to me. He told me they weren't dating. He told me he had stopped talking to her yet I just saw them together in a club, holding hands. What am I supposed to think? Am I supposed to think that they bumped into each other in the club coincidentally? I guess I am at fault here. Brenda, Fred, and I go to different clubs every week to have fun, and Cart's Club is one such club. I never gave it any thought that we would meet there. We only went to Cart's Club once. We had a regular club downtown and we frequent there more, I guess that is why I never thought I was going to run into them there. I was only making an effort to cheer Ryan up and make him stop brooding over his mother's sickness. I even thought he was going to act lovey-dovey wi